I chose to live in England although my life was far better in Italy.
I first came as a student and paid for my accommodation and school with foreign money. When I finished university, I came back and worked at the Italian Embassy, paid by the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. I spent my foreign money in UK. I am still doing so. I work hard within my community because I simply cannot sit still. Yet, there are people like the 'bigoted' woman Gordon Brown had the misfortune to encounter who may accuse me of coming to this country for scrounging, just because I was born elsewhere.
Am I an immigrant? No, I am not. I am a person who chose to live in this country because I fell in love with it. I contribute to it and enrich it with my presence. As long as the UK is in the EU, I have a legal right to be here. I am tired of hearing platitudes from people who cannot even write in their own mother tongue, who cannot read a decent newspaper (and may have never read a decent book), who display crass ignorance and arrogance. They should be ashamed of themselves as they shame the UK.
Are they the minority or the majority? I want to believe they belong to the former group.
Gordon Brown did not call the woman a xxxxxxx xxxx but 'bigoted'. He was very mild in his appraisal. I heard far worse from other politicians in Croydon and elsewhere. He spoke his mind but he should have done so in front of her and stopped her when was going on about 'flocks' and 'swamps'.
I found Ian Dunt's article interesting. I wonder how many people may appreciate it and also how the gutter press will deal with Brown's so called 'gaffe' tomorrow.
You can see why he is so dejected. The gaffe is symbolic of the sense the public has that politicians are secretly sneering at them. They are all smiles at election times and then abject distaste behind closed doors, locked in their shiny, beautiful cars.
Duffy herself could not have been better picked: retired, widowed, working class and eloquent - she is perfect for the tabloids. Perhaps they created her out of stem cells.
But - and I imagine I'll get my fair share of hate mail for this - Brown had a point. This is what Duffy said about immigration: "All these eastern Europeans that are coming in - where are they flocking from?" Beyond the fact that she has answered her own question, this statement is profoundly problematic. This sort of talk about immigrants has become more and more acceptable, but we would do well to remind ourselves that it is not acceptable to use animal or geographic metaphors about immigrants. Talk of 'flocks' and 'swamps' serve to cement a sense of immigrants being 'the other'. They are not so different to us. They marry us, drink beer with us, work with us and live side by side with us.
Brown himself is actually as guilty as anyone of allowing the rhetoric of the far-right to corrupt the mainstream debate, by popularising that primitive and narrow-minded phrase 'British jobs for British workers'. But it is not tolerable for people to discuss immigrants in this way, and it reflects badly on the character of the person speaking.
But Brown's behaviour was undeserving of the criticism he has received for another, broader reason: he did what you do everyday.
We all have two faces: our social face and our private face. Nobody loves everyone in their office, or everyone in their extended family. We show our smiling social face in the day, ask people we are utterly uninterested in about their children, and then we go home and complain about how boring they are to our partner over dinner. That is normal human behaviour, not least of all in Britain, which is still more private than most other countries.
If we despise the robotic version of politicians which have invaded our TV screens, the pre-programmed Cabinet-level automatons who emit soundbites and vacuity, then we must accept that politicians will behave like humans. They are not moral paradigms and we must accept that behaviour we would tolerate in a friend or colleague should be tolerated from them as well. This disproportionate reaction to their all-too-human failings will just provide us with another generation of political robots.
The attack that's currently underway won't fade quickly, and it will frame perception of his performance in Thursday's TV debate, which he desperately needs to win. But Brown isn't particularly out of order - you've done the same thing yourself. Glass houses and all that.
Recent Comments